It’s what people want – In that case it’s what they deserve

A recent thread started by Herd (“One who doesn’t understand X is best qualified to talk about it”) reminded me of the following events, which are even worse than Herd’s point.

A couple of years ago I went to see my doctor about a torn ligament in my shoulder. She was away and so I saw a locum instead. This locum was an elderly lady but presumably sufficiently qualified, and up to date, to practice for the NHS. I told her the problem and she gave me her solution. It was to take a homeopathic medicine. Obviously I was appalled. And had she not been such a sweet old thing I would have given her a piece of my mind!

I went back a few weeks later, saw my usual doctor, and told her what had happened. She said that she sympathized, she was obviously ‘scientifically’ trained herself. “But,” she said, “this is what people want these days.”

And this was more frightening than the old dear with her quack remedies.

What does it matter what people ‘want’? We aren’t talking brand of mobile ‘phone here. How can untrained laypeople ever understand the meaning of ‘science’ and the ‘scientific method’ when even the scientists are colluding in this nonsense?

Well, Darwin will prevail in the end and with a bit of luck practitioners of homeopathy and all their patients and advocates will eliminate themselves from the gene pool.

BTW the proper doctor arranged for some physio for my shoulder and I’m fine now, thanks for asking.

P

Related Posts

Misinterpreting The Evidence I saw a news story recently saying something like there are more germs on your iPhone than on a toilet seat. From which we conclude what? We are to...
Where Do You Keep Your Offshore Money? Where do you keep your offshore money? The media is all upset about celebs, politicians, etc. having money in various offshore places, in order to ...
Bloomberg View Columnist Barry Ritholtz Interviews... Listen to Barry Ritholtz interview Paul Wilmott about quantitative finance, mathematical modelling, reputational risk, Tom Cruise, JK Rowling, Billy J...
Boris Johnson, Yanis Varoufakis And Sir Vince Cabl... Boris Johnson, Yanis Varoufakis and Sir Vince Cable all have something in common…. All three have been in the news lately with their interpretation...
Webcast – Paul Wilmott On “The Money F... Paul recently gave a talk in downtown Manhattan about his new book, co-authored with David Orrell, The Money Formula. Other topics get dragged in alon...
Jeremy Corbyn: My Part In His Ascent First, disclosure: I am rather right wing, from the school of "take some of my income in taxes but otherwise leave me alone, please." And as a general...
The Money Formula – New Book By Paul Wilmott... The Money Formula: Dodgy Finance, Pseudo Science, and How Mathematicians Took Over the Markets OUT NOW!!! Explore the deadly elegance of finance's...
Ed Thorp: A Man For All Markets The book we've been waiting for, the full story of Ed Thorp's career in mathematics, science, gambling, and finance. An inspiration for us mortals. ...